Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

a family or a neighborhood is the bedside

English answer:

see fuller explanaton of sentence

Added to glossary by Stephanie Ezrol
Jan 1, 2010 03:28
14 yrs ago
1 viewer *
English term

a family or a neighborhood is the bedside

English Art/Literary Poetry & Literature
I make no argument for impoverished vitality, nor do I plead the cause of those who enjoy poor health. Yet how often do we find that the confessional of a family or a neighborhood is the bedside of one who sees the green fields only as did the Lady of Shalott, by holding a looking-glass so that it reflects the out-of-doors. Let me carry that simile one step further, and say that the mirror of the soul when kept free from fleck and stain, reveals the beauties of the universe. And I am not sure but that the soul, freed from the distractions of sense and the trammels of flesh, glides away to a height where things are observed for the first time in their true proportions.
Change log

Jan 4, 2010 13:45: Stephanie Ezrol Created KOG entry

Responses

+6
2 hrs
Selected

fuller explanaton of sentence

to make sense of this you have to look at 3 elements of the sentence.

1. Yet how often do we find that the confessional
Confessional refers to the place, or the moment, where confessions of sins are made.

2. of "a family or a neighborhood"
meaning that a family or an entire neighborhood will sometimes make confessions of sin.

3. is the "bedside of one who sees the green fields only as did the Lady of Shalott, by holding a looking-glass so that it reflects the out-of-doors."

This is a reference to the Lady of Shallot, from a poem by Tennyson, who suffered a curse, and was locked in a tower. She made tapestries only by seeing reflections of the landscape in a mirror. She could never see anything directly.

So the reference is the one to whom the confessions are made (at the besides of that person-- alluding to the idea that the confession are made besides the bed of that person). The literary reference is to the idea of confessing to one who knows by the mind's reflection, not by directly seeing.
Peer comment(s):

agree Jack Doughty
2 hrs
Thanks Jack, and Happy New Year.
agree Annett Kottek (X) : See also below.
3 hrs
Thanks Annett, and Happy New Year.
agree Jenni Lukac (X)
4 hrs
Thanks Jenni, and Happy New Year.
agree Tony M : Yes — 'confessional' is of course being used purely figuratively here: a place / time when people tell their most intimate secrets; the bed-ridden person (a bit of hype there too!) sees a distorted image of the world through the people recounting it.
9 hrs
thanks Tony, and Happy New Year.
agree Paula Vaz-Carreiro
1 day 4 hrs
Thanks Paula
agree Phong Le
2 days 21 hrs
Thanks Phong Le
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "thanks!"
10 hrs

a family or a neighborhood- the only means available to make a picture

You should really look into the meaning of "confessional"."Bedside" - is a priest's attention, the only words to the priest before dieing, something that is a pain, the only sorrow, narrowmindness.So, the author acuses these people of being too SHORT-SIGHTED. Lady of Shalott who used a magnifying glass in order to "scrutinize" her garden in minuture- was mentioned by the author in sense "to make something great small", to see in a light of a prizm of the personal (limited by own family/neighbourhood) interests.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 10 hrs (2010-01-01 14:24:33 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

"...representing a narrowmindedness"

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 10 hrs (2010-01-01 14:26:43 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

minuture- in miniature - typo
Peer comment(s):

neutral Tony M : The Lady of Shalott didn't use a manifying glass, but was obliged to observe the world through its reflection in a mirror; rather undermines what seems to be your basic argument, I feel?
1 hr
The idea of camera obscura was in mind of Tennyson.However, you are right,she didn't scrutinize, but caught a glimpse of - and this fact is important for translation.Sorry.
Something went wrong...

Reference comments

5 hrs
Reference:

Family members or neighbours prefer to go to the bedside of one..

..who is bedridden to confess their sins. The author argues that people more readily open up to someone who is physically handicapped because they believe such a person to have greater insights into the affairs of the world/to be wise. Physical disability turns out to be an advantage as such persons are not hindered in the search for knowledge or truth by sensuous experience. The author repeats an ancient prejudice that sees physical existence as inferior (it will 'fleck and stain' the soul) to intellectual being.

Full text: http://www.web-books.com/Classics/ON/B0/B905/04MB905.html
Peer comments on this reference comment:

agree Alexandra Taggart : "free from fleck and stain " - impeccable in sense "obscured" - "camera-obscura has too many unnecessary objects in front of it.
5 hrs
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search