Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

a false opposition

English answer:

the two are not really opposed to each other

Added to glossary by Ana Juliá
Mar 4, 2016 09:38
8 yrs ago
1 viewer *
English term

a false opposition

English Art/Literary Religion About the book of Proverbs
It is sometimes said that the Wisdom Literature is separate from the rest of the OT, lacking an interest in God’s choice of Israel and his overarching purpose for the nations, the law, the temple and priesthood, and sacred history. Wisdom Literature, it is said, is more about living in the creation than it is about God’s work of redemption. This is ***a false opposition*** for several reasons.
First, the OT presents God’s redemption as restoring the damaged creature, man, to his proper functioning (as set out in the creation narrative of Genesis). This covenant given through Moses does not specify all of God’s rules; its purpose is to set out the constitution of the theocracy, to give general moral guidance, and to provide a system by which God’s people can know his forgiveness. Some principles like those in Proverbs can be discerned by wise observation of God’s world, and not all of the worthy observers come from Israel (see note on Prov. 31:1–9). Second, the wisdom psalms take wisdom themes and make them a part of Israel’s hymnody (and thus of its public worship). Third, Proverbs bases its instruction on the fear of the Lord (1:7, using the special covenantal name of God), implying that its audience is the covenant people (cf. Deut. 6:2, 24; 10:12). Fourth, as the notes will show, Proverbs has plenty of connections to the law: e.g., cf. Proverbs 11:1 to Deuteronomy 25:13–16; and see Proverbs 29:18 for a positive assessment of both prophetic vision and the Law of Moses.

Responses

+6
57 mins
Selected

the two are not really opposed to each other

The text is saying that the claim that "Wisdom Literature" is concerned with "living in the creation" rather than "God’s work of redemption", the latter being the concern of the OT, is wrong because the two concerns are not opposed to each other and, in fact, coexist. The argument based on claiming they are opposed is, therefore, flawed.
Peer comment(s):

agree Charles Davis : Exactly. I think it means that the opposition between "living in the creation" and "God's work of redemption" is false, and consequently the corresponding opposition bewteen Proverbs and the rest of the OT is also false.
0 min
Thanks Charles. Yes.
agree Robert Forstag
28 mins
Thanks Robert
agree Daryo : it's a "fake" opposition // there isn't any
1 hr
Thanks Daryo
agree Yvonne Gallagher
1 hr
Thanks Gallagy
agree philgoddard
2 hrs
Thanks Phil
agree Harry Crawford
3 days 15 hrs
Thanks Harry
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you!"
+1
3 mins

an argument based on flawed logic

...is the straightforward meaning of " a false opposition" your text then goes on to outline precisely why it is considered false;
Peer comment(s):

agree acetran
2 days 18 hrs
Something went wrong...
-1
55 mins

full of contradictions

Wisdom literature contains full of contradictions, and they are stated in the second paragraph.
Peer comment(s):

disagree Daryo : you'd need a truckload of poetic licence to interpret it that way, and even then .... most would think that on the contrary there isn't really any (contradiction)
1 hr
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search