Glossary entry

Russian term or phrase:

ПОДРОБНАЯ ОЦЕНКА ДИЗАЙНОВ (МОНАДИЧЕСКАЯ ЧАСТЬ)

English translation:

detailed design testing (monadic section)

Added to glossary by Adieu
Nov 30, 2007 10:20
16 yrs ago
1 viewer *
Russian term

ПОДРОБНАЯ ОЦЕНКА ДИЗАЙНОВ (МОНАДИЧЕСКАЯ ЧАСТЬ)

Russian to English Marketing Other quantitative anlysis
а монадическая это...?
Proposed translations (English)
4 monadic
3 +1 monadic

Discussion

Marina Mrouga Nov 30, 2007:
Поздравляю с моментом истины :-)
Adieu (asker) Nov 30, 2007:
scary, innit? ...marketers using multiple statistical tools to analyze something sensible?!

That report had more graphs and numbers than it had words. What ever happened to endless vague unsubstantiated claims like "our study has shown that, generally, more often than not, sometimes consumers overall prefer..." ?!

If this dark trend continues, the fastest way to make a few extra hundred without ever turning on your brain might just go down the toilet. Bugger ;-(
Adieu (asker) Nov 30, 2007:
ПОЧТИ ЧТО... докопался до истины: монадика есть рассмотр каждого образца по отдельности, а дальше их противопоставляют друг другу... там получается чудная вещь, что образец, который с наивысшей вероятностью нравился потребителю сам по себе, при сравнительном рассмотрении в ряду других образцов получил самые низкие баллы. МатАн тут не при чем, а вот про то, что один аргумент помогло - так и догадался. Потом и заказчик почесался - подтвердил.
Marina Mrouga Nov 30, 2007:
А другие виды количественного анализа предлагаются? Мне кажется, что просто используется мудреное название, чтобы обозначить количественный анализ. У меня есть знакомые коллеги, которые любую мысль доводят таким заумным образом.
Adieu (asker) Nov 30, 2007:
monadic-то оно и есть, то понятно! ...просто приятно иногда знать, о чем собственно переводишь!
Adieu (asker) Nov 30, 2007:
hmmm... is this part of the ridiculous trend to derive all sorts of words from "triad" that seems to be the craze in marketing? does this, in fact, mean individual?

Proposed translations

12 hrs
Selected

monadic

I'm a mathematician who has also worked in marketing, so I am familiar with this term from both worlds.

The correct translation *is* "monadic," (as already suggested by Marina.M) but not for the reason she cited. Her citation was from a different field, Mathematics and Computer Science, where "monad" is a very common term referring to an operator or function which takes only one argument (in this sense, "monadic" = "unary"), or specfically in Category Theory (a field in Mathematics), where it refers to a particular type of functor.

So *none* of the uses of the term "monad" on the following wiki page are applicable to marketing tests:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monad

Now, let's find a citation from the world of marketing tests, where "monadic" simply means a product test involving just one product:

http://www.burke.com/Services/CMR/services.cfm?id=15

***Monadic*** Product Tests. In ***monadic*** testing, a respondent tests a single product and provides an evaluation of that product. Data collected typically includes variables such as purchase interest and ratings on attributes. If there is more than one product to be tested, matched groups of respondents would test each product, with the data collected from each group being compared to each other.

Paired Comparison Product Tests. In a paired comparison test, respondents use two products in sequence, with no questioning in between. After both products have been used, they are asked to rate each and state a preference. Because questions are not asked until both products have been tried, the evaluation of a product is always in the context of a comparison to the other.

There are other comparative type test designs, such as triangle and triad tests (evaluating three products in sequence), as well as variations such as repeat paired comparison designs, but they are all essentially modifications of comparative testing designs. Generally, however, when deciding upon the appropriate test design, the first decision must be "***monadic***" or "comparative"?

===

This is the example of "monadic" you were looking for!
Something went wrong...
1 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you for confirming this. However, since you added this (admittedly excellent) explanation several hours after I explained the term in the notes section of the question, I am giving you just one point."
+1
8 mins

monadic

ну, монадический - это monadic, один из видов арифметики. Можно переводить дословно


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monadic_predicate_calculus
Monadic predicate calculus
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
In logic, the monadic predicate calculus is the fragment of predicate calculus in which all predicate letters are monadic (that is, they take only one argument), and there are no function letters. All atomic formulae have the form P(x), where P is a predicate letter and x is a variable.



--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 9 mins (2007-11-30 10:30:26 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Да, я тоже согласна с Adieu, что это искусственное усложнение (ложная наукообразность) текста
Peer comment(s):

agree Alexander Demyanov
1 hr
Спасибо, Александр!
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search