Glossary entry (derived from question below)
English term or phrase:
affiant [pronunciation]
English answer:
Normally stressed on the second syllable: uh - FEYE - unt [second syllable rhymes with the word \"eye\" and the word as a whole rhymes with \"defiant\"]
English term
affiant [pronunciation]
I ask because there are web references indicating two very different pronunciations:
1. uh - FEYE - unt (accent on second syllable, which rhymes with "eye")
2. AH - fee - unt (accent on first syllable, which has a short "a" sound, with an unstressed second syllable that rhymes with "bee."
Thanks in advance!
4 +4 | Normally stressed on the second syllable: uh - FEYE - unt | Charles Davis |
4 -1 | əˈfīənt | airmailrpl |
Sep 5, 2017 17:55: NancyLynn changed "Visibility" from "Visible" to "Squashed"
Sep 5, 2017 19:03: Enrique Cavalitto changed "Visibility" from "Squashed" to "Visible"
Sep 10, 2017 20:14: airmailrpl changed "Edited KOG entry" from "<a href="/profile/55340">Robert Forstag's</a> old entry - "affiant [pronunciation]"" to ""əˈfīənt [accent on second syllable, which rhymes with \"eye\"; word as whole rhymes with \"defiant\"]""
Sep 13, 2017 20:56: Enrique Manzo changed "Removed from KOG" from "affiant [pronunciation] > əˈfīənt [accent on second syllable, which rhymes with \"eye\"; word as whole rhymes with \"defiant\"] by <a href="/profile/21987">airmailrpl</a>" to "Reason: Incorrect grading"
Responses
Normally stressed on the second syllable: uh - FEYE - unt
Most Internet sources indicate that it is stressed on the second syllable in the United States, as in your option 1. Merriam-Webster, for example, gives only this pronunction: "\ə-ˈfī-ənt\"
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/affiant
This view is not unanimous. Here is a YouTube video in which an American who looks as though he may be a lawyer firmly stresses it on the first syllable, AFFiant, as in your option 2:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CX1uSEc22q8
However, to me the clinching reference is Black's Law Dictionary, surely the most authoritative source in the U.S. for legal terminology. In the 8th edition, supervised by Bryan Garner (generally recognised as the leading American expert on legal language), the
pronunciation is explicitly indicated in the entry for this
word:
"affiant (<<schwa>>-fI-<<schwa>>nt)"
https://imeumanahchambers.files.wordpress.com/2015/02/blacks...
(foot of p. 177).
To me, this clinches the matter. There are clearly those (in the U.S.) who pronounce it the other way, but stressing it on the second syllable must be regarded as the standard pronunciation.
Thank you, Charles! |
agree |
Tony M
: Can't argue with your reasoning... those as a Brit, my natural tendency would have been the other way.
1 hr
|
Thanks, Tony! I have to admit that I had never thought about this before.
|
|
agree |
lorenab23
: Yes, stressing it on the second syllable is how I hear it day in and day out during depositions (I interpret an average of 5 a week)
3 hrs
|
Thanks, Lorena! That's what we needed: someone with first-hand experience :)
|
|
agree |
mike23
: Great explanation, Charles. It should be stressed on the second syllable as the standard pronunciation.
19 hrs
|
Thanks very much, Mike :)
|
|
agree |
acetran
1 day 18 hrs
|
Thanks, acetran :)
|
əˈfīənt
af·fi·ant
əˈfīənt/
noun
Law
noun: affiant; plural noun: affiants
a person who swears to an affidavit.
disagree |
Tony M
: That's exactly the same as Charles's answer, except that you don't actually explain the pronunciation.
10 mins
|
phonetic : /əˈfīənt/.
|
Discussion
By the way, I'm not averse to being Quixotic myself when it suits me!
Actually, affiant and defiant are not unrelated etymologically. Affiant comes from Vulgar Latin affidare, via FR affiance and EN affiance; defiant comes from Vulgar Latin disfidare, via FR desfiance and EN defiance.
If pronunciation reflected etymology, we ought to be saying "DEFFiance" and "DEFFiant". Maybe English speakers once did stress these words on the first syllable, but certainly no one does now. If the tonic accent can shift to the I in these words, there's surely no reason why it shouldn't do so in affiance and affiant as well.
I'm quite prepared to accept the consensus, of course — I should hate to be Quixotic! — whilst acknowledging that there is however a certain lack of logic to it! And we do know that there are often detail differences between US and GB pronunciation — let's take 'laboratory' as a common example!
On the British side, Oxford and Collins both give the pronunciation of this word as əˈfaɪənt: stressed on the second syllable. That is the consensus on both sides of the Atlantic, as far as reference works are concerned. In fact I haven't yet found a dictionary that says the opposite.
I can't help wondering how many of the people whose voices you hear there have ever used this word in conversation. I'm not sure I ever have, not being a lawyer. So on what basis are they pronouncing it one way or the other, I wonder? Genuine personal experience? Guesswork? Looking it up? Following a script organised by someone behind the scenes? This, of course, is a general problem with user-generated sites: how do we know whether the users know what they're talking about?
əˈfīənt
nounLAW
a person who swears to an affidavit.